Introduction
The US housing market has been under pressure in recent years, with many attributing the rise in home prices to a severe housing shortage. However, a recent study highlights that there are 5.6 million vacant homes across the country’s 50 largest metropolitan areas, with an average vacancy rate of 7.37%. This raises a crucial question: If so, why are so many homes vacant? Is there a housing shortage?
Housing Shortage: The Reality Behind the Vacancy Data
While millions of homes sit vacant, this doesn’t mean the US housing market is oversupplied. Many of these homes are temporarily unoccupied, and their availability doesn’t necessarily address the more significant housing issues, such as affordability and inventory for homebuyers and renters.
There are several reasons why homes might be vacant:
-
Rental Properties Awaiting Tenants: A significant portion of vacant dwellings are rental units currently listed on the market but not yet rented. Rental vacancy rates have increased in some areas as rental inventories have recovered.
-
Seasonal or Recreational Properties: Many vacant homes are used as vacation properties, such as beach houses or cabins. These homes are typically occupied only during specific times of the year and are not part of the housing supply for year-round residents.
-
Personal or Family Use: Some properties remain vacant because owners hold onto them for personal reasons, such as waiting to sell or keeping them for future family use.
Housing Supply vs. Demand
Vacant homes don’t significantly alleviate the broader issue of housing supply shortages. Housing demand still far outpaces supply. Homeowner vacancy rates are currently around 0.9%, and rental vacancy rates stand at 6.6%, near historic lows. This shows that available housing for homeowners and renters is still scarce, driving up competition and lowering prices.
Additionally, the for-sale housing market remains undersupplied, with inventory levels more than 20% below what they were before the pandemic. This lack of available homes for purchase continues to support high home prices, even as buyer demand slows.
Will Vacancies Lower Housing Prices?
Despite the number of vacant homes, it’s unlikely they will cause a significant decrease in home prices. Several factors, such as location, mortgage rates, and property characteristics, heavily influence prices. Moreover, many of these vacant homes are either seasonal or temporarily unoccupied, meaning they are not readily available for purchase or long-term rental.
As a result, the overall inventory of homes for sale remains low, supporting elevated prices in high-demand areas.
Areas with the Highest Vacancy Rates
Cities with the highest vacancy rates often have solid seasonal trends. For instance, popular vacation spots like New Orleans and Miami have double-digit vacancy rates due to the nature of short-term rental demand, which tends to fluctuate throughout the year.
The Impact on Future Housing Development
Despite the number of vacant homes, the housing shortage highlights the need for strategic development moving forward. While many properties are vacant for short-term reasons, the persistent demand for affordable and accessible housing continues to push prices up, particularly in metropolitan areas.
This dynamic calls for an increase in new housing developments, especially in cities where housing is scarce, and prices are out of reach for many potential buyers. Policymakers and developers need to focus on creating more affordable housing options, not just luxury or seasonal properties, to meet the needs of everyday Americans.
Additionally, cities and states may need to reconsider zoning laws and building regulations to allow for higher-density housing in areas with skyrocketing demand. By encouraging the development of more diverse housing options, such as apartments, condos, and townhomes, the market can better respond to the growing population and shifting homebuyers’ preferences.
While the presence of vacant homes can create the illusion that there’s plenty of housing available, the reality is more complex. The focus must remain on ensuring the housing market meets its residents’ needs, which will likely require significant investment in new construction, regulatory reform, and innovative housing solutions over the coming years.
Beyond Vacant Homes
The US housing market’s challenges go beyond vacant homes. Although millions of properties sit unoccupied, these are often seasonal or temporary vacancies that do little to alleviate the broader housing supply issues. To address the shortage, stakeholders must prioritize affordable, accessible housing development and implement changes that allow for growth where needed. High prices and limited availability will characterize the housing market for years without these adjustments.
