The COVID-19 pandemic sparked a dramatic migration trend in the United States: a widespread departure from big cities in favor of suburban, exurban, and rural communities. Known as the “urban exodus,” this movement was fueled by health concerns, remote work opportunities, and the pursuit of more affordable living. But as the pandemic wanes and cities adapt, a pressing question arises—are Americans still leaving major urban centers, or is the tide turning?
The Pandemic Shift: A Quick Recap
From 2020 through 2021, large cities across the United States—particularly San Francisco, New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago—saw significant population declines. Urban residents, particularly younger professionals and families, sought larger homes, private outdoor spaces, and less densely populated areas. According to U.S. Postal Service change-of-address data, millions relocated, contributing to booming suburban housing markets and rising rents in areas previously considered remote.
At the same time, remote work became mainstream. Freed from the obligation to live near their offices, workers pursued lower costs of living, better quality of life, or simply more space. The traditional appeal of urban centers—walkability, nightlife, short commutes—waned under the threat of a global health crisis and the realities of lockdown life.
Recent Migration Trends: What the Data Says
While the initial rush out of cities has slowed, data shows the urban exodus hasn’t ended entirely. According to U.S. Census Bureau data and studies from real estate platforms like Redfin and Zillow, many Americans continue to favor suburban and exurban areas over urban cores. Major metro counties such as Los Angeles, Cook (Chicago), and New York still reported net population losses in 2023, albeit at slower rates than during the height of the pandemic.
Goldman Sachs economists analyzing these trends found that urban counties experienced net domestic outflows of more than half a million residents annually between 2021 and 2023. Although this trend appears to be stabilizing, it remains above pre-pandemic norms.
Interestingly, while cities themselves lost population, many metro areas still grew due to international immigration, higher birth rates, and growth in surrounding suburban counties. This paints a more nuanced picture—Americans may be moving out of dense city centers, but not necessarily abandoning metro areas altogether.
What’s Driving the Continued Exodus?
Several long-term factors continue to influence migration away from big cities:
1. Remote and Hybrid Work:
Even as companies recall employees to the office, a significant portion of the workforce remains remote or hybrid. According to a Pew Research study, around 25% of U.S. employees now work remotely at least part-time. This flexibility enables people to prioritize affordability, space, and lifestyle over proximity to the office.
2. Cost of Living:
The cost of living in major cities remains prohibitively high for many. San Francisco, New York City, and Los Angeles consistently rank among the most expensive housing markets in the country. For many families and young professionals, the value proposition of urban living has diminished.
3. Quality of Life and Safety Concerns:
Suburban and exurban areas often offer cleaner environments, larger living spaces, and perceived safety—especially appealing to families with children. Meanwhile, some urban residents cite crime, homelessness, and deteriorating infrastructure as reasons for leaving.
4. Changing Life Stages:
Millennials—the largest generational cohort—are entering life stages that typically involve homeownership and childrearing. These milestones traditionally push people toward the suburbs, where they can find more space, better schools, and quieter neighborhoods.
5. Taxes and Business Climate:
High-income individuals and business owners are increasingly relocating to states with no income tax, such as Texas, Florida, and Tennessee. This trend continues to affect cities like New York and San Francisco, which rely heavily on wealthy taxpayers to fund public services.
Where Are People Going?
While every region has its unique appeal, a few patterns have emerged:
-
Sunbelt Cities: Austin, Phoenix, Raleigh, and Tampa continue to attract new residents with their warm climates, growing job markets, and relatively lower housing costs.
-
Exurbs: Communities 30 to 60 miles outside metro cores are seeing some of the fastest growth in the country. These areas offer a middle ground between rural living and metro access.
-
Smaller Metros and Lifestyle Towns: Boise, Asheville, and Salt Lake City appeal to remote workers seeking a blend of culture, affordability, and natural beauty.
-
Tax-Friendly States: Texas and Florida have seen the highest inflows of high-earning households due to the absence of state income tax and a more business-friendly environment.
Are Cities Making a Comeback?
Although the urban exodus continues in some form, signs of urban resurgence are also appearing. Immigration, student inflows, and the return of cultural and economic activity are helping cities like New York and Chicago rebound. Rental prices in some areas have rebounded to pre-pandemic levels, and certain neighborhoods are experiencing revitalization thanks to local policy efforts and private investment.
Additionally, the lines between urban and suburban are blurring. Many suburbs are developing walkable downtowns, mixed-use communities, and cultural centers to compete with urban amenities. This hybridization suggests that while traditional urban cores may not regain all their pre-pandemic residents, the appeal of city-style living persists.
What Does This Mean for the Future?
The post-pandemic real estate landscape is one of fluidity and flexibility. The urban exodus isn’t as dramatic as it was in 2020–2021, but it hasn’t stopped. Instead, migration trends are reflecting deeper societal changes:
-
People are choosing lifestyle over location.
-
Work no longer binds many Americans to city centers.
-
Affordability is a key driver of movement.
-
Suburbs and exurbs are growing more attractive and dynamic.
For city governments, these trends present both challenges and opportunities. To retain and attract residents, cities must address affordability, invest in public safety and transportation, and adapt to a hybrid workforce. Failing to do so could lead to prolonged fiscal stress and diminished competitiveness.
Conclusion
So, are Americans still leaving big cities? The answer is yes—but not with the urgency or volume seen during the early pandemic. What we’re witnessing is not a rejection of cities, but a rebalancing of urban and suburban life. Cities remain vital centers of culture and commerce, but they must evolve to meet the needs of a more mobile, discerning, and digitally connected population.
The urban exodus is now part of a broader reshaping of how and where Americans choose to live—a transformation likely to influence urban planning, housing policy, and the future of work and the big cities for years to come.
